Friday, February 24, 2023

EveryCubEver: Billy Herman

    I've been working on revising the book for the upcoming 5th edition (which will be out on Opening Day). Thought I'd share a few of these EveryCubEver entries with you while I worked...


Billy Herman 1909--1992 (Cubs 1931-1941)
He was named William Jennings Bryan Herman after the famed orator, and this Billy had an incredible big league career. He was a 10-time All-Star in 15 big league seasons (and his first two years, the All-Star game hadn’t been invented yet). He was considered the best hit and run man to ever play the game. His lifetime batting average was .304. He led the league in hits, doubles, triples, and sacrifices, but he was even better known for his glove. In his 15 years as a second baseman he led the league in putouts seven times, not to mention leading the league in assists, fielding percentage, and range. And he was elected into baseball’s Hall of Fame in 1975. But sadly, Herman didn’t spend his entire career with the Cubs. The team somehow traded him to the Dodgers in 1941. Leo Durocher, the Dodgers manager at the time, tells how this happened in his book Nice Guys Finish Last. He was traded to the Dodgers at four in the morning. According to Durocher, who got this information directly from his GM (MacPhail), the trade was made during a night of drinking. MacPhail was invited to the suite of the Cubs GM Jim Gallagher when the Cubs were in New York. MacPhail was a well-known drunk, but he figured out pretty quickly that Gallagher and manager Jimmy Wilson were trying to get him drunk to talk trade. So, instead of drinking the brandy, MacPhail only pretended to drink it while he was actually pouring it out in flower pots, toilet bowls, and wherever else he could. Meanwhile, every time the Cubs poured MacPhail a drink, they also poured themselves one. Instead of getting him drunk, they got themselves drunk. By 4 AM MacPhail had acquired the best second baseman in baseball in exchange for a backup outfielder and a utility infielder. The deal was put in writing on the back of an envelope. And yes, MacPhail’s grandson later became the president and general manager of the Cubs: the infamous Andy MacPhail. 
Billy Herman still holds the Cubs record for most hits on Opening Day. He got five in 1936.